Last verified October 12, 2026. Rule cited: English Language Proficiency Out-of-Service Criteria, notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 51422, FR Doc. 2026-16288, Docket FMCSA-2026-0826, published August 10, 2026. Comment period closed October 9, 2026; no final rule published as of October 12, 2026.

On August 10, 2026 the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration published a notice of proposed rulemaking that would make a driver’s failure to meet the English language proficiency standard in 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2) an out-of-service violation written into the regulations themselves. Much of the coverage has described this as a new enforcement action. It is not. Drivers have been placed out of service for English proficiency since June 25, 2025. The proposal changes where the consequence lives, not whether it exists.

In one paragraph

The standard does not change. Enforcement does not change today. If the rule is finalized, a new 49 CFR 391.11(c) will require a driver found in violation of 391.11(b)(2) in interstate commerce to be placed out of service immediately, with the existing border commercial zone exception kept on a trip-by-trip basis, and 391.11(b)(2) will be added to the definition of “out-of-service order” in 390.5 and 390.5T. The comment period closed October 9, 2026; FMCSA is reviewing the comments and has not published a final rule.

How we got here

  • The standard is old. 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2) has required since 1937 that a driver read and speak English well enough to converse with the public, understand highway traffic signs and signals, respond to official inquiries, and make entries on reports and records.
  • April 28, 2025. Executive Order 14286 directed FMCSA to enforce the standard.
  • June 25, 2025. The Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance added ELP noncompliance to the North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria, and FMCSA’s enforcement policy directed inspectors to place violators out of service.
  • February 3, 2026. The Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026 (Public Law 119-75) directed the Secretary of Transportation to update the regulations so that noncompliance with 391.11(b)(2) triggers an out-of-service order.
  • April 16, 2026. FMCSA memo MC-SEE-2026-0002 and its FAQs set the current procedure, including the trip-scope rule for the border commercial zones.
  • August 10, 2026. The notice of proposed rulemaking, implementing the statutory directive.

What the proposal would change

A new 391.11(c). Paragraph (c)(1) would require that any driver found in violation of 391.11(b)(2) while operating in interstate commerce be placed out of service immediately. Paragraph (c)(2) would keep the exception for the U.S. and Mexico border commercial zones designated under 49 CFR Part 372, Subpart B, but only where there is no evidence that the driver has operated, or intends to operate, beyond the zone on the trip. That is the same trip-scope test FMCSA has applied since April 16, 2026.

The definition of an out-of-service order. 391.11(b)(2) would be added to the lists in 390.5 and 390.5T, which is what gives the consequence its legal weight for penalties and for the driver’s record.

Durability. FMCSA explains that writing the consequence into the regulation means every state must adopt a compatible requirement as a condition of Motor Carrier Safety Assistance Program funding, regardless of any future change to the CVSA criteria. In plain terms, it becomes much harder to reverse.

What the proposal would not change

  • The standard itself. 391.11(b)(2) is not amended. What a driver must be able to do is the same.
  • What happens at roadside today. The CVSA criteria and the April 16, 2026 policy remain in force while the rulemaking runs.
  • The training picture. FMCSA states in the proposal that it does not require motor carriers to train their drivers in English, and that carriers may establish their own programs or use existing training materials. Training is preparation for a qualification the carrier must assess; it is not a mandate and it does not substitute for the assessment.
  • Guidance for drivers who are deaf or hard of hearing. FMCSA’s 2014 guidance (79 FR 59139) remains in effect.

The numbers FMCSA published

The proposal is the first place FMCSA has put its own enforcement data on the record:

  • January 1 to June 24, 2025: 7,812 ELP violations, 33 out-of-service orders.
  • June 25, 2025 to March 19, 2026: 60,399 ELP violations, 19,045 out-of-service orders, all outside the border commercial zones.
  • In the same period, 44,354 violations were recorded inside the border zones with no out-of-service order.
  • FMCSA estimates the proposal would add roughly 9,000 out-of-service orders a year inside the border zones, at an estimated annual cost to carriers of $14.4 million, using $800 a day of vehicle downtime over an average two days to source a replacement driver.

Read the other way: roughly one in three ELP violations outside the zones already ends in an out-of-service order. The proposal would make it every one.

What carriers should do now

  1. Assess at hire and document it. English proficiency is part of driver qualification under 49 CFR Part 391, Subpart B. FMCSA’s guidance FMCSA-DQ-391.11-FAQ001 describes how a carrier may assess it during the qualification process. Put the assessment, and who did it, in the driver qualification file.
  2. Check trips, not addresses. Inside the border commercial zones, relief depends on the trip staying inside the zone. A driver dispatched beyond the zone is checked to the full standard wherever the stop happens.
  3. Prepare drivers for the assessment format. The roadside assessment is an interview in English followed, if needed, by highway sign recognition. Interpreters, I-Speak cards, cue cards and translation apps are not allowed during the assessment. Practice with the sign set and the officer questions is the preparation that helps.
  4. Know what a DataQs request can and cannot do. A request for review corrects a factual error on an inspection report. It does not remove a correctly recorded violation, and neither does training.
  5. Follow the docket if the border zone exception matters to you. The docket is FMCSA-2026-0826 at regulations.gov. The comment period closed October 9, 2026; the comments filed, including those on the border zone impact estimate, are public on the docket.

Frequently asked questions

Is English proficiency an out-of-service violation right now?

Yes, under the CVSA out-of-service criteria and FMCSA’s enforcement policy, since June 25, 2025. The proposed rule would write that consequence into 49 CFR 391.11 itself.

When would the proposed rule take effect?

Not before a final rule is published. The comment period closed October 9, 2026; FMCSA must now review the comments and publish a final rule with its own effective date.

Does the rule require drivers to take an English course?

No. FMCSA states that it does not require carriers to train drivers in English. The carrier must make sure each driver meets the qualification; training is one way to prepare for it.

What is the border commercial zone exception?

Inside the commercial zones designated under 49 CFR Part 372, Subpart B, a driver who fails the assessment is cited but not placed out of service, provided the trip stays inside the zone. If the driver has operated or intends to operate beyond the zone, the exception does not apply.

Sources

  • 91 FR 51422, FR Doc. 2026-16288, Docket FMCSA-2026-0826, federalregister.gov/d/2026-16288
  • 49 CFR 391.11, 390.5, 390.5T, Part 372 Subpart B, current text at ecfr.gov
  • FMCSA English Language Proficiency enforcement policy and FAQs (MC-SEE-2026-0002, April 16, 2026), fmcsa.dot.gov
  • Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026, Public Law 119-75, congress.gov
  • Executive Order 14286, 90 FR 18759 (April 28, 2025), federalregister.gov

DotMotusCompliance Inc. is a private compliance services provider. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of FMCSA, the U.S. Department of Transportation, or any government agency. Our ELP Driver Training course is preparation for a qualification standard the motor carrier must assess; it does not change anything already on a federal record. This post is general information, not legal advice.

Scroll to Top